According to MLB.com, Judge’s OPS+ of 257 is tracking as the highest legitimate April in league history, better than anything posted by Babe Ruth or Ted Williams. He’s one of only three Yankees, alongside Lou Gehrig in 1927 and Mickey Mantle in 1956, to tally at least nine homers and hit over .400 through the team’s first 30 games.

Judge is putting up numbers that would be unrealistic for a video game, yet Aaron Boone claimed he’s not even on fire yet.

His April report card was even better. With the last-place Orioles prevailing 5-4 on Wednesday night, the first-place Yankees lost two of three with Judge finishing the first full month of the 2025 baseball season with three more sensational performances.