Rhoades cost Rock his triumphant return match against Reigns, thanks to his loyal fan base, which demanded to see him finish his story at WrestleMania 40. He did, with some help in the form of The Undertaker thwarting interference from Rock, but only after being pinned by The Final Boss the previous night.

The members of the WWE talent were confused instead of disappointed after the event. On his appearance at The Pat McAfee Show, He explained he stepped aside to allow Cena and Cody Rhodes to take the spotlight.